Almost every large project starts in a meeting room and, sooner or later, runs into the same question: will we need an EIA? The answer changes the schedule, the budget and the relationship with the people who live around the site. If you are planning to build or invest in Brazil, it is worth understanding what is at stake before you sign any study contract.
What exactly is an Environmental Impact Study?
The Estudo de Impacto Ambiental, or EIA, is a technical study carried out before the decision on a project is made. It exists to answer a simple question: what changes in the territory, in the environment and in people's lives if this project goes ahead?
The foundation is constitutional. Article 225, paragraph 1, item IV, of the Brazilian Federal Constitution requires a prior environmental impact study, made public, for any work or activity that may cause significant environmental degradation. Federal Law 6,938/1981, which created the National Environmental Policy, placed impact assessment and environmental licensing among the instruments of that policy. CONAMA Resolution 001/1986 (CONAMA is the National Environmental Council) then defined the minimum content of the study.
The EIA always comes with a RIMA, the Environmental Impact Report. The EIA is the full technical document. The RIMA is the version the public can actually read.
When is an EIA/RIMA required?
Not for every project. It is required when an activity may cause significant environmental degradation. CONAMA Resolution 001/1986 gives an illustrative list that includes larger roads, railways, ports, sanitary landfills, transmission lines, mining, power plants, industrial districts and large urban developments. States and municipalities may add their own requirements.
In practice, the licensing agency decides case by case and defines the scope of the study in a terms of reference. Lower-impact activities usually call for lighter studies, and their names and formats vary from state to state. My advice is never to assume. Talk to the agency early, while the project is still being designed.
What must an EIA contain?
Resolution 001/1986 organizes the study into parts that appear in virtually every serious EIA:
- an analysis of technological and location alternatives, including the option of not carrying out the project;
- an environmental diagnosis of the area of influence, covering the physical, biological and socioeconomic environments;
- identification and assessment of impacts, positive and negative, direct and indirect, immediate and medium to long term;
- measures to avoid, mitigate or offset negative impacts;
- monitoring and follow-up programs.
The same resolution requires the study to be prepared by a qualified multidisciplinary team that is not directly or indirectly dependent on the project proponent. This is not a bureaucratic detail. It is what gives the document credibility before the agency, the Public Prosecutor's Office and the community.
Why does the socioeconomic environment weigh so much?
Because that is where the impact meets people. The socioeconomic chapter deals with who lives and works in the area of influence, land use, economic activities, infrastructure, ways of life and the relationship between the project and its neighbors. It is where you find out, for example, that the access road designed to solve a construction problem cuts across the route children take to school.
This is the chapter that suffers most from shortcuts. Tables copied from secondary sources, with no fieldwork and no listening, produce a diagnosis that looks good and tells you nothing. My doctoral research at the University of São Paulo deals with how people perceive flood risk, and it reinforced something I bring to licensing work: what a community perceives as risk does not always match what the technical map shows. Ignoring that gap tends to be expensive later, in conflict, in tense public hearings and in conditions that are hard to meet.
What usually stalls the process?
From what I see when reviewing reports, delays rarely come from one big failure. They come from small weaknesses that pile up:
- a terms of reference read too quickly, leaving required items unanswered;
- a poorly justified area of influence, too large or too small for the impacts the project really causes;
- a diagnosis built on old data, with no fieldwork to confirm current conditions;
- a generic list of impacts, similar to other studies, with no assessment of significance or magnitude;
- mitigation measures with no owner, no deadline and no indicator, which makes them impossible to monitor;
- chapters by different specialists that contradict each other;
- a public hearing that was poorly prepared, where the RIMA does not answer the questions of the people in the room.
Then there is the agency's own timeline. CONAMA Resolution 237/1997 sets a maximum review period of twelve months when an EIA/RIMA and a public hearing are involved, but the clock stops every time the agency asks for additional information. Each request that goes back to the developer is a stopped clock. A study that is coherent from the first submission is, in practice, the best schedule management tool you have.
What should the RIMA say, and to whom?
The RIMA is read by residents, councils, associations, prosecutors and the local press. Resolution 001/1986 asks for accessible language, illustrated with maps, charts and graphs, so that the advantages and disadvantages of the project and all the environmental consequences of its implementation can be understood. If the RIMA only repeats the jargon of the EIA, it fails at its main purpose, which is transparency. The public hearing, regulated by CONAMA Resolution 009/1987, is where that quality shows, for better or for worse.
How can you commission an EIA without surprises?
A few questions help separate a good study from one that only ticks boxes:
- Who is on the team, and what experience does each person have with this type of project?
- Does the schedule allow for fieldwork in the right season, and not only the client's ideal deadline?
- Is someone responsible for stitching the chapters together and checking the coherence of the whole before filing?
- Will the socioeconomic environment have its own survey, listening to the affected groups?
- Will the RIMA be written for the people who will read it, and not only for the agency?
That last point matters especially for consultancies that outsource reports. A review and finalization stage, with an outside eye on consistency, writing and alignment with the terms of reference, avoids much of the back and forth with the licensing agency.
If your company, construction firm, municipality or consultancy is facing an EIA/RIMA, or needs a second look at a report in progress, I would be glad to talk. You will find the contact details on this site.


